0029735: Wrong accounting of the cost adjusment lines under some circumstancies (Goods Movement)

Openbravo Issue Tracking System - Openbravo ERP

View Issue Details

Project

Category

View Status

Date Submitted

Last Update

0029735

Openbravo ERP

04. Warehouse management

public

2015-04-28 16:39

2015-05-04 12:13

Reporter

VictorVillar

Assigned To

aferraz

Priority

urgent

Severity

major

Reproducibility

always

Status

closed

Resolution

fixed

Platform

OS Version

Product Version

Target Version

3.0PR15Q2

Fixed in Version

3.0PR15Q2

Merge Request Status

Review Assigned To

umartirena

OBNetwork customer

Web browser

Modules

Core

Support ticket

Regression level

Regression date

Regression introduced in release

Regression introduced by commit

Triggers an Emergency Pack

Summary

0029735: Wrong accounting of the cost adjusment lines under some circumstancies (Goods Movement)

Description

Wrong accounting of the cost adjusment lines under some circumstancies (Goods Movement)

Steps To Reproduce

As group Admin role,
  Go to Product window:
    create a new one
    Name: test
  Add a purchase Price list: Tarifa bebidas
  unit/list price: 5

Costing Rule assigned to the organization should be "Average".

Go to Purchase Order:
   Create a new one for this product: qty: 10
Complete it.
Go to Goods receipt window,
  Create the lines from the Purchase Order created before.
  Storage Bin: RN- 2-0-0
Complete it.

Go to Goods movement,
  create a new one with this product.
  From: RN-2-0-0
  to: RN-0-0-0
Complete it

Go to Product window:
  create a new one
  Type: service
  name: transport
Accounting tab:
Asset Account : 62400 Transportes
Product Expense : 62400 Transportes

Go to Landed Cost Type document:
select the Distribution by Amount algorithm
select the product: Transport

Create a landed cost document --> Cost 20 assigned to the Goods Receipt created before. Process it

Launch the Costing Background process and realise that the transactions have been calculted.

Go to Cost Adjustment document and Post it.
The entries posted are the ones related to the Goods Movement transaction which needs also to be adjusted.

Realise that the journal entry is:

35000 Productos terminados A Debit: 40.00
61000 Variación de existencias de mercaderías Credit: 40.00

That is wrong, as the net effect of the adjustment accounting should be 0.

Proposed Solution

Therefore correct posting should be:

(1) In the case of NOT allowing Negative Posting.

The journal entry for the Movement From transaction must be:

61000 Variación de existencias de mercaderías Debit: 20.00
35000 Productos terminados A Credit: 20.00

The journal entry for the 'Movement To' transaction must be:

35000 Productos terminados A Debit: 20.00
61000 Variación de existencias de mercaderías Credit: 20.00

(2) In the case of allowing Negative Posting.

The journal entry for the Movement From transaction must be:

35000 Productos terminados A Debit: -20.00
61000 Variación de existencias de mercaderías Credit: -20.00

The journal entry for the 'Movement To' transaction must be:

35000 Productos terminados A Debit: 20.00
61000 Variación de existencias de mercaderías Credit: 20.00

Additional Information